Don’t Conceal — Mine Your Model’s Flaws for Storytelling Gold


Your model is flawed.

It doesn’t matter who you might be or what your organization does. The character of your model is flawed. Manufacturers behave badly in main and minor methods. Even essentially the most well-intentioned model efforts go awry. 

Elon Musk has arguably purposely acted out to devalue X’s model worth. Bud Gentle had a foul model 12 months in 2023 with a flawed advertising marketing campaign. Even modern startup OpenAI unintentionally created a model problem after firing and re-hiring its CEO and co-founder Sam Altman.

In fact, model character errors additionally occur in smaller and far much less catastrophic methods. Not less than one e-mail in all probability sits in your inbox from an organization addressed to <NAME> or that tries to promote you one thing you already bought from the model.

As entrepreneurs, you hope to keep away from these conditions. However right here’s the factor: Firms, organizations, and types are made up of individuals. Folks make errors, and folks do unhealthy issues. Each certainly one of your manufacturers will falter sooner or later.

Nonetheless, in all these conditions lies a lesson on your position as a model storyteller.

Understanding your model’s flaws

Stephen R. Covey, creator of seven Habits of Extremely Efficient Folks, as soon as wrote, “We choose ourselves by our motives and others by their habits.” As people, you proceed making this basic attribution error when perceiving your actions vs. others’ actions.

You often know the clear intentions behind your personal actions, however guilt could make you double down when somebody calls out your response. You already know it was an accident if you reduce off that automotive. However when that driver roars alongside beside your automobile, flips the hen, and screams from inside their automotive, you double down and flip them the hen, shouting, “Oh shut up. I didn’t do it on objective!”

You know you labored exhausting on that e-mail marketing campaign for buyer enablement. However when it goes out prematurely with a mistake and also you cynically get known as out on social media, you react poorly, additional inflaming the error.

Bud Gentle’s marketing campaign that includes Dylan Mulvaney is an ideal instance. As I’ve written, the beer model’s greatest mistake was not the marketing campaign however its response to the backlash and, extra importantly, its lack of preparation for the backlash.

Figuring out flaws’ potential in your model tales

When issues go improper, you almost certainly blame the scenario and remind your self of your intentions. However your notion of different folks’s — and different manufacturers’ — habits is totally different. You don’t know their intentions. Even when they specific them, you could ignore them. You almost certainly interpret their habits as a flaw of their character.

As entrepreneurs, recognizing this tendency to judgmental responses supplies an vital lesson.  It makes a robust case for a extra expansive strategy to model storytelling than simply speaking about your services or products.

Traditionally, model messaging architectures should be idealized, good, and unassailable — a passionate voice hanging a perfect chord in an imperfect world. Your model is the answer to all that ails. You develop causes for that perception, a spotlight, and a price.

You pay little or no consideration to exposing weaknesses and flaws.

However it’s best to. Each nice hero has flaws. It’s what makes their strengths and story so relatable.  Luke Skywalker has a darkish facet. Barbie initially lacks self-awareness. Even George Bailey in It’s A Great Life — the right father, brother, and buddy — has self-worth points.

In storytelling, the hero’s flaw lays the inspiration of the story’s battle and compels audiences to have interaction. Then, isn’t it ironic that you simply, as entrepreneurs, need your model story to be so uneventful and freed from battle when that would by no means be?

Embracing imperfection

As 2024 unfolds, companies should lean exhausting into their human-centered model story. The disruption of generative AI and noise within the market ought to compel you to create extra human content material that differentiates by way of model storytelling.

Leaning into model content material inherently implies it’s essential to get exterior the consolation of “protected” model messaging and take greater leaps into thought management, participating tales, and purpose-driven content material. You need to take a better probability of misinterpretation, errors, or plain ol’ riskier content material.

Final 12 months, I shared point-of-view message structure. Within the intervening months, I’ve labored with extra purchasers to assist them assume by way of how a lot and the place they align, not solely on the model messaging parts however all of the issues the model believes.

A core aspect of that structure requires recognition that every standpoint consists of “resistances.” These aren’t simply the damaging or opposition of the advantages or values. These resistances acknowledge the failings on this standpoint.

We helped a worldwide consulting agency develop a point-of-view structure round the way forward for cloud computing as tech infrastructure. The standpoint and model story have been constant throughout their enterprise models. One resistance materialized as a result of they struggled to reside as much as that idealized infrastructure. However as soon as acknowledged, we may tackle it.

We didn’t spotlight this flaw within the messaging. Simply because the model was flawed in dwelling the best didn’t imply they couldn’t imagine and advertise. Nonetheless, recognizing the flaw did lead the agency to arrange a constant, cohesive, and aligned response ought to they ever get known as out on the flaw.

As a marketer, you’re the good candidate to carry your model’s flawed character. You need to have the power, braveness, and developed muscle to speak your intentions to reside as much as your model’s beliefs. And it’s essential to additionally settle for that you simply by no means totally will.

It’s your story. Inform it effectively.

Subscribe to workday or weekly CMI emails to get Rose-Coloured Glasses in your inbox every week. 


Cowl picture by Joseph Kalinowski/Content material Advertising Institute