I Tried Instagram Automation (So You Don’t Have To): An Experiment


Has the elusive unicorn of Instagram automation ever tempted you?

We are able to’t blame you. Instagram automation software program websites paint a reasonably image of your telephone blowing up organically with likes and feedback. Your social media scales effortlessly whilst you sit again and loosen up.

Manufacturers like Nike, NASA, and whoever runs Obama’s social networks are begging you to seek the advice of.

And, oh, who’s that in your DMs? Taika Waititi and Doja Cat each asking for a comply with again? Wow, that is every part you dreamed of, proper?


I attempted it out, and never solely did Doja Cat not return any of my messages, however I additionally misplaced time, cash, and a little bit of dignity.

All will not be misplaced; there are legitimately useful Instagram automation instruments. We’ll get to them on the finish of this text. However first, right here’s what occurred once I tried Instagram automation.

What’s Instagram automation?

To be clear, the sort of Instagram automation we’re discussing are bots that like posts, comply with accounts, and remark in your behalf.

Ideally, you prepare your bots to sound and act such as you. Then, these bots exit and discover accounts they assume you’ll like. They work together with them utilizing parameters you’ve set beforehand in a hopefully pure method.

The thought is that by partaking with different accounts, these accounts will flip round and interact with you. This fashion, you’ll be constructing a following with actual folks by utilizing a bot to do the work.

However, very like pals in actual life, you possibly can’t use a robotic to foster relationships for you. Wall-E varieties excluded, in fact. It’s impersonal, and folks are inclined to know when a bot is pretending to be an individual, and folks hate it.

And when folks on Instagram hate one thing, Instagram tends to hate it too and bans rapidly comply with. They need their actual customers to fortunately spend as a lot time as attainable on the app, in order that they take black-hat social media methods fairly critically.

Instagram automation is a type of pesky black-hat methods, like engagement pods, which we tried and, spoiler alert, they failed. It’s in step with shopping for Instagram followers. We tried that too, and it left us with an inflated follower depend, zero engagement, and an extended listing of clearly pretend followers.

What’s NOT Instagram automation?

Let me be crystal clear: There are glorious, legit Instagram automation instruments and software program on the market. They do the groundwork for you, letting you deal with ways that may authentically scale your social efforts, like creating content material your followers wish to see.

Within the context of this text, we’re discussing Instagram automation practices which are black-hat ways. The legit instruments we all know and love don’t fall underneath this umbrella. We’ve listed a couple of of our favourite instruments and software program on the finish of this piece.

What occurred once I tried Instagram automation

Now that we’re on the identical web page with what “Instagram automation” means, we will get into the nitty-gritty.

I began off by doing what you most likely did to get right here — I Googled “Instagram automation.” I landed on Plixi, one of many first marketed Instagram automation choices on Google. It appeared like a great place to start out.

Experiment 1

Step 1: Enroll

Enroll was fast and straightforward. I linked my Instagram account and put in my bank card data. I used an outdated account that solely had 51 Followers, so the one method to go was up!

Plixi’s dwelling web page bragged about having a “patent-pending” mannequin. Basically, they’re crawling Instagram and utilizing machine studying to search out and work together with like-minded accounts, partaking with them, and inspiring followers.

Step 2: Development Settings

After signing up, Plixi requested me to set my progress settings. The free (for twenty-four hours earlier than you must pay for a month at $49) model permits you to select “gradual” in your follower progress. Gradual it’s.

I added in “accounts like mine” so Plixi may goal their followers, assumedly. This was a bit powerful because the account I used to be utilizing — Scholar Collars — was a foolish trend line I launched originally of the pandemic.

What’s Scholar Collars, you ask? I created collared dickies for these last-minute oh-my-God-I’m-still-wearing-pajamas Zoom conferences.

You may preserve one in your desk drawer, then slap it on underneath your t-shirt or sweater for an immediate skilled improve. On Zoom, you possibly can solely see your neck and shoulders, so the opposite assembly attendees assume you’re in stylish enterprise informal put on.

As you possibly can see, it wasn’t precisely simple to search out comparable accounts, so I added @Zoom.

There have been a couple of different choices to arrange my account for achievement, however they had been all gated behind a Professional account.

Step 3: Begin

I slapped the Begin Development button, and Plixi began discovering me new followers. I had one inside the first 2 minutes — a crypto app account.

Plixi additionally advised me in my exercise dashboard that that they had “Reached 9 customers based mostly on @zoom” although it’s unclear what that really means. They hadn’t reached out to 9 customers so far as I may inform.

Step 4: Watch my followers develop

After 24 hours, I had eight extra followers, taking me from 51 to 59. The subsequent day my follower depend grew to 100. Over every week, my follower depend grew to 245, which is fairly okay — it wasn’t as low-cost and straightforward as different methods to purchase followers. However, the accounts appeared legit, and the expansion was gradual sufficient that Instagram didn’t appear eager to flag my account.

However, I now had 245 followers and nonetheless solely seven likes on one in all my images. And no exercise from my very own account. I had been underneath the impression that Plixi would additionally like and remark from my account. It didn’t.

The expansion was fantastic and all, however what’s actually the purpose? For $50, I had no engagement apart from a rise in follower depend. And since Plixi hadn’t interacted with different accounts, I couldn’t make certain the place the followers had been coming from, nevertheless it wasn’t from natural engagement.

So, Plixi was a letdown. However, like all good researcher, I attempted a second experiment.

Experiment #2,

Step 1: Discover an Instagram remark bot

After Plixi, I needed to focus my efforts on automating engagement. Naturally, I Googled “Instagram remark bot and automated Instagram likes”

I discovered one which robotically sends out DMs. Yikes. That appeared too private one way or the other. And one other that promised me it was an actual particular person, which, if you happen to’ve learn our chatbot do’s and don’ts, you’ll know is a chatbot-don’t.

Instaswift gave the impression to be extra what I used to be after — and so they marketed a free Instagram-like-bot trial. Offered.

Step 2: Attempt the Instagram bot totally free

The free Instagram bot turned out to be 10 to fifteen free likes in your final three uploaded footage. After I tried it, I used to be met with an error message. Off to a rocky begin with Instaswift.

Instaswift Free Live Demo

Supply: Instaswift

Step 3: Pay for it

Per week of Instaswift with 3-4 feedback is $15, so regardless of the frustration from the free trial, we’re nonetheless going forward. Perhaps they deal with paying prospects just a little higher.

Step 4: Submit a photograph

It’s important to put up a brand new picture for it to start out working, and the one I selected of my good friend’s cat Gus bought 110 likes and 4 feedback. The surge in likes would have regarded pretend if I hadn’t accomplished the follower marketing campaign first. Now, it solely seems pretend if you happen to look carefully.

fake comments for Gus the cat

I opted to cancel my subscription because it robotically renews from week to week.

Now, I simply needed to discover a bot to remark from my account.

Experiment 3

Step 1: Discover a remark bot

For the third experiment, I attempted PhantomBuster. It promised to put up feedback from my account robotically.

Plus, it had promised Instagram automation totally free with a 14-day trial. Offered.

Step 2: Enroll and get began

PhantomBuster makes use of cookies to log in to your account to remark in your behalf. As soon as I had that sorted, it requested me for a spreadsheet with put up URLs and remark examples.

Then, I despatched Phantom Buster to ‘go’ and sat again.

Step 3: Test your outcomes

The bot robotically commented on three posts. However, they had been the three account URLs and feedback I had added to the spreadsheet. It might have taken me much less time to touch upon the posts myself.

automatic comments by post on Instagram posts

If this wasn’t a free trial, I might be upset that PhantomBuster billed me for doing one thing I may have accomplished myself.

Classes from Instagram automation

Instagram automation is not any secret path to instafame or much more engagement. It turned out to be a waste of money and time for me.

There’s no such factor as a legit, risk-free Instagram automation service

As Hootsuite writers Paige Cooper and Evan LePage every found after they ran this experiment, automating Instagram advertising and marketing and engagement ain’t it.

Paige Cooper tried three totally different websites: InstaRocket, Instamber, and Ektor.io. She described her experiment as “shockingly ineffective” after gaining and shedding lower than ten followers. Although, Paige did wind up with some feedback — notably, “Why did u purchase followers” and “U have small likes.”

Evan LePage used the now-defunct Instagress to get 250 followers in 3 days. He reported:

“I [automatically] commented “your pics > my pics” on a selfie of a boy who was clearly in center faculty. In reality, his account was composed of solely 4 footage, three of them selfies. I felt uncomfortable. The teenage boy advised me I used to be being modest.”


And as for myself, the expertise was a lunch bag letdown. Sure, I bought a couple of new followers and a few feedback. However, in the end, the followers weren’t aligned with my model and the feedback

There isn’t any method to automate Instagram legitimately, successfully, and with out threat.

It’s not well worth the time looking and organising

One of many greatest frustrations I discovered was that looking for “legit” (AKA apps that didn’t look too sketchy) automation manufacturers took effort and time. Then, organising every of them to work with my Instagram account and checking in on them took effort and time, too.

If I had spent the identical period of time simply engaged on a social media technique, I might be in a a lot better place proper now.

Legitimately useful Instagram automation instruments

Now for the great half. All hope will not be misplaced relating to useful Instagram automation instruments. Like most issues in life, there’s no magic wand you possibly can wave to get what you need. However, there are magic wands that may make your workday a bit simpler.

Hootsuite’s Scheduling Software program

Scheduling software program permits you to plan your Instagram posts forward, so that you don’t should scramble the day of. Hootsuite’s scheduling options are a dream for busy content material creators and entrepreneurs — and key to saving you time in your social media advertising and marketing efforts.

Hootsuite Analytics

Instruments for Instagram analytics and metrics can automate reviews for you, so you possibly can see what’s working and what’s not and pull reviews simply for shoppers or managers that present outcomes throughout all of your social media platforms. We’re clearly just a little biased, however we do love Hootsuite Analytics, and social media managers do too.


Chatbots for Instagram can alleviate the drudgery of FAQs, buyer assist, and gross sales — you simply have to search out one you possibly can belief. We love Heyday — a lot in order that we partnered with them.

Heyday permits you to handle all your buyer’s queries from a single dashboard, so your Instagram DMs are simple to verify. And, it automates messages for you, like regularly requested questions.

Heyday chatbot for Instagram

Supply: Heyday

Hootsuite’s social listening instruments

Social listening and hashtag monitoring instruments can crawl for key phrases necessary to your model. You may arrange a seek for related matters, see who’s saying what on the market, then remark again.

Begin constructing your Instagram presence the actual method utilizing Hootsuite. Schedule and publish posts on to Instagram, interact your viewers, measure efficiency, and run all of your different social media profiles — all from one easy dashboard. Attempt it free at the moment.

Get Began

Simply create, analyze, and schedule Instagram posts, Tales, and Reels with Hootsuite. Save time and get outcomes.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here